November 19, 2026
The Palm Beach County Property Appraiser's page for lot 145 at Old Marsh Golf Club lists seven recorded transfers. The newest one breaks a pattern. The house sold for $4,332,795 on August 26, 2026, and the line below it shows the same house selling for $5,075,000 on April 14, 2025. Before that, each warranty-deed sale on the lot had come in higher than the one before: $2,290,000 in April 2021, $2,990,000 in March 2022 and $4,350,000 in June 2023.
Set beside the other Old Marsh deeds recorded this year and the land values the Property Appraiser assigns each lot, that resale fits what the rest of the records show. The ground under an Old Marsh home is valued almost the same from lot to lot, and the house on top is the part whose price moves.
Old Marsh has roughly 60 single-family homes and no condos or villas. Between January 2020 and March 2026, about nine homes a year changed hands. In 2025 there were ten closings at a median of $4.68 million, and every one was a cash purchase. With that few transactions, a median can swing on one estate. It makes more sense to look at the individual sales.
The addresses all say Palm Beach Gardens, but the Property Appraiser lists each Old Marsh parcel as unincorporated Palm Beach County, with the subdivision recorded as Old Marsh Golf Club at 7500 Old Marsh Rd. The county's parcel pages are where every figure below comes from.
A fifth Old Marsh home closed earlier in the year, at $6.55 million in February 2026, according to MLS sales data. The four warranty-deed sales recorded from April through mid-November 2026 can be lined up against their county land values:
| Lot | 2026 sale date | 2026 sale price | Prior recorded sale | 2026 county land value |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lot 4 | April 10, 2026 | $5,500,000 | $600,000, Sept. 2006 | $2,062,470 |
| Lot 128 | August 3, 2026 | $3,660,000 | $3,325,000, June 2023 | $2,040,520 |
| Lot 145 | August 26, 2026 | $4,332,795 | $5,075,000, April 2025 | $2,122,540 |
| Lot 45 | September 8, 2026 | $2,700,000 | $1,300,000, June 2004 | $2,058,980 |
These four prices run from $2.7 million to $5.5 million, a gap of $2.8 million. The land values run from $2,040,520 to $2,122,540, a gap of about $82,000. Nearly all of the price difference across the four sales is in the house.
On the 2026 tax roll, each of these four lots carries a land value between $2.04 million and $2.12 million. You can see that number at work in the September sale.
The house on lot 45 had one recorded purchase before this year, $1,300,000 in June 2004, and it sold for $2,700,000 on September 8, 2026. The lot's 2026 land value is $2,058,980. That leaves about $641,000 of the price for the house itself, a 1998 home that had been held by the same owner since 2004.
So the least expensive recorded Old Marsh sale of 2026 was mostly a land purchase. The county's land figure is a tax-roll valuation, not a market appraisal or a sale price, but four lots in a row landing within $82,000 of each other says the community's lots are close to interchangeable on paper. Whatever separates an Old Marsh home at $2.7 million from one at $5.5 million is in the house: its age, size, condition and how it sits on the lot.
At the top of the four, the house on lot 4 sold for $5,500,000 on April 10, 2026. Its land value is $2,062,470, nearly the same as lot 45's. About $3.44 million of that price was for the house, or more than five times what the buyer on lot 45 paid above land.
Lot 128 sits between the two. It sold for $3,325,000 in June 2023 and for $3,660,000 on August 3, 2026, a gain of roughly 10 percent over a little more than three years. On a land value of $2,040,520, about $1.62 million went to the house. The parcel also shows a $10 warranty deed in September 2025, which is a transfer of title with no money behind it and doesn't count as a sale.
That brings things back to lot 145.
The house on lot 145 was built in 2000 and sits on 0.78 acres. The county shows it selling for $742,205 less than the April 2025 price, about 14.6 percent lower after 16 months. The land under it held its value. The Property Appraiser's land figure for lot 145 went from $2,037,540 in tax year 2025 to $2,122,540 in tax year 2026. The drop came out of what the buyer would pay for the house.
The 2026 price is also within $20,000 of the June 2023 sale at $4,350,000. Over the long run the house has gained a great deal since its 2021 sale, and the 2026 buyer paid about what the market paid three years earlier.
A single sale can come in low for many reasons, including timing, terms or a seller's own plans, and a deed records none of them. What the record does show, together with lot 128's modest gain, is that the house is where an Old Marsh price can give back ground, while the land figure under it kept rising.
If standard lots are close to interchangeable, the one place land acts differently is where someone combined lots. One Old Marsh parcel covers lots 81 through 83 on the county's legal description. Its recorded sales are $475,000 in 2005, $500,000 in 2014 and $1,025,000 in 2015, and a home was built on it in 2018. Its 2026 land value is $4,522,420, a little more than twice a standard lot's, and its total 2026 market value on the roll is $12,128,455.
At Old Marsh, the only way to get more land than a standard lot is to buy from the neighbors. The community is surrounded by preserve land, and it has 456 Audubon-certified acres, a figure that covers the course and the natural areas as well as the homesites. That fixed supply keeps the land value steady, and it is why the land value works as a floor for every sale.
Put the four recorded 2026 sales together and an Old Marsh purchase splits into two decisions. The first is the lot, which the county values about the same almost everywhere in the community. Differences in view and exposure still matter to buyers, and those you judge by walking the property. The second is the house, and that is where this year's prices spread out, from about $641,000 above land on lot 45 to about $3.44 million on lot 4.
For a buyer, this means the checks that matter most are on the house: age, systems, layout and what work the home will need. On lot 145, a price set at the high end of the community's recent sales did not hold from 2025 to 2026. On lot 45, a 1998 house sold for not much above the land under it. A buyer weighing either kind of home is mostly deciding whether that house is worth keeping as it stands or whether they plan to rebuild on the lot.
Membership is its own decision. The club describes membership as invitation-only, with a deliberately limited number of equity memberships, and says both residents and non-residents may join. The course has been on the same footing for years. The club's most recent stated renovation was a 2016 project guided by Pete Dye and the Dye family, and it says the wetlands and wildlife were preserved in that work. Anyone comparing it with a larger club nearby can look at our guides to Old Palm and Bear's Club. Our recent piece on how scarcity is priced at Bear's Club looks at a community of similar size priced differently.
How many Old Marsh homes sold in 2026? Five through mid-November 2026: a $6.55 million closing in February, according to MLS sales data, and four warranty-deed sales the county recorded from April through September at $2.7 million to $5.5 million.
What is an Old Marsh lot worth on its own? For tax year 2026, the Property Appraiser values each of the four lots that sold this year at between $2.04 million and $2.12 million. That is the county's figure for the tax roll, not a market appraisal.
Is Old Marsh inside Palm Beach Gardens? The homes have Palm Beach Gardens mailing addresses, but the county lists the parcels as unincorporated Palm Beach County.
If you're deciding whether an Old Marsh house is worth keeping or whether you're mainly buying the lot, Hughes Browne Group can go through the deed history and land value of any property you're looking at, and our Old Marsh guide is a good place to begin. Start a Conversation, and bring the parcel numbers.
Whether by land or by sea, the properties and amenities in South Florida are of the highest quality, and this group of Real Estate Agents certainly follows suit.